World War II - D-Day Essay example

1120 Words 5 Pages

Throughout the course of World War II, there were several American raids, or invasions, of European soil. Young American soldiers risked their own lives in order to save those of thousands of others. The most famous of these invasions happened on the beaches of Normandy, Where US and British forces ran into a strong German resistance . This battle has been studied and glorified by many American historians throughout the years. Every historian has his or her own take on this event, but almost all American historians will express it as an important United States victory.

In his article “Questionable Objective: The Brittany Ports, 1944”, A. Harding Ganz focuses on the “logistical planning” and “strategic considerations” of
…show more content…
He does go a little more in depth than Ganz while describing policies; he also portrays those men who made the policies. Powers describes General Bernard L. Montgomery, overall ground commander for the battle of Normandy, as a “vain, self-centered, troublesome general”.

Ganz and Powers clearly glorify the D-Day battles, and attribute the allied victory to these incidents; Joseph Forbes has an entirely different view of this particular invasion. He suggests that there were several other battles that are worthy of attention and praise. When discussing the planning of a possible invasion of Japan, He is quoted as saying:

“But James has presented no evidence that the adjustments in the Olympia invasion planning would preclude an invasion of Japan in late fall. General
(Dwight D.) Eisenhower, commander of the Normandy invasion, has pointed out that several serious problems were encountered in the planning of
Overload, and the plans were altered and adjusted several times. Yet all the
Problems and adjustments did not stop D-Day from taking place.”

This shows that Forbes feels that there were several different battles that could have been the turning point of the war, but they were ignored. The above quote hints that he feels that an invasion of Japan was placed in the shadows of Operation Overload during the planning phase of the war.

Dropzone Normandy, by Napier Crookenden, as well as Ruth Chenault’s D-Day:

Related Documents

The Expanse S03E12 VOSTFR HDTV | Soft drink | [Read more...] about Operation Mekong 2016 BRRip 720p Dual Audio In Hindi Chinese